Coca-Cola Arctic Home White Cans: Good Move?

Recent­ly, Coca-Cola has received some back­lash from the release of the Arc­tic Home white cans. It is the first time in the company’s 125-year his­to­ry that the cans are not most­ly red. So, was the deci­sion to pro­duce these lim­it­ed-edi­tion white cans a good one or was it a poor strat­e­gy to raise aware­ness?

As some­one who has worked on Coca-Cola Hol­i­day pack­ag­ing for a few years, I was pleas­ant­ly sur­prised to see that Coca-Cola was real­ly going to make a state­ment this year by pro­duc­ing lim­it­ed-edi­tion white cans. I was espe­cial­ly pleased that Coca-Cola was try­ing to do some good by part­ner­ing with the World Wildlife Fund to help pro­tect the polar bear’s habi­tat. In years past, I was used to high­light­ing chances to win a PS3 or XBox360 on hol­i­day pack­ag­ing. The white cans seemed like a refresh­ing change that would real­ly force con­sumers to take notice, and I applaud Coca-Cola for tak­ing this risk.

How­ev­er, now I am remind­ed that most peo­ple are afraid of change — par­tic­u­lar­ly if the change seems out of their con­trol. Peo­ple lit­er­al­ly freaked out over the fact that their Coca-Cola cans were no longer red. Some peo­ple even believed the secret for­mu­la tast­ed dif­fer­ent in the white cans. On a recent flight, I over­heard a flight atten­dant com­plain­ing to a pas­sen­ger that she has trou­ble telling the dif­fer­ence between the white Coca-Cola can and the sil­ver Diet Coke can. It turns out she is not alone in this con­fu­sion despite the seem­ing­ly obvi­ous dif­fer­ences between the cans.

Because of this, Coca-Cola will be phas­ing out to red Arc­tic Home cans (although the com­pa­ny says it was always part of the plan — who knows?). Is this the right deci­sion? Does this mean the white cans were a mis­take?

Coca-Cola Arctic Home cans

At first I thought the cam­paign was a great idea, but in hind­sight I now think a change in strat­e­gy could have made the white cans suc­cess­ful. I believe con­sumers felt as though the white cans were forced on them and they had no option to drink out of their beloved red cans. So, what if Coca-Cola released both the white and red Arc­tic Home cans togeth­er instead of phas­ing from one to the oth­er? What if white cans could only be found in select fridge packs? Would they then be desired and sought after instead of reject­ed?

I remem­ber when Star Wars Episode 1 came out and Pep­si fea­tured the main char­ac­ters on its cans. I feel like a dork admit­ting it, but my sis­ter and I kept buy­ing more and more Pep­si (although we were typ­i­cal­ly Coke drinkers) because we want­ed to col­lect all the char­ac­ters. Think about it. Dif­fer­ent Coca-Cola pack­ag­ing is usu­al­ly desired and even sought after by die-hard fans and col­lec­tors. Peo­ple loved the Coca-Cola Hol­i­day orb bot­tles that were sold the past few years. Maybe the com­plete change to white was just too much too soon for most con­sumers.

If fridge packs were the only way to find the white cans, then that would elim­i­nate the con­fu­sion for peo­ple reach­ing for sin­gle cans at con­ve­nience stores. Most peo­ple who sell indi­vid­ual cans would be pur­chas­ing in larg­er bulk sizes that would not include the white cans. Even the busi­ness­es that do pur­chase and sell cans from fridge packs would still have a major­i­ty of red cans to sell to those who pre­fer them. The exte­ri­or of fridge packs would remain red, so peo­ple would have no con­fu­sion at gro­cery stores.

I think this could have been a way to make peo­ple excit­ed when they found one or two white cans in with the red cans in their fridge pack. Maybe then peo­ple would have paid more atten­tion to the cause than the pure shock of the dis­ap­pear­ance of red Coke cans.

What do you think?